TopArrow vs GitHub, App Store and SaaS apps
App stores, GitHub, SaaS apps, AI app builders and TopArrow each have their place. Here is how they differ, for people who use software and for people who make it.
If you use software
What matters: does it work right away, can you change it, and where does your data live.
| Question | TopArrow | App stores | GitHub | SaaS apps | AI app builders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ready to use once installed? |
Yes, and the code is in your hands
|
Yes, you get a finished app
|
Usually you build or deploy it yourself
|
Yes, open the website or app
|
You describe it first, then generate and debug
|
| Can you change what does not fit? |
Yes, tell an AI coding tool what to change
|
No, you wait for the developer to update it
|
Yes, but you usually need to code and set up the tooling
|
No, you can only send feature requests
|
Only what you generated, and it gets error-prone as features pile up
|
| Is your data on your own device? |
Yes, it stays on your device
|
Depends on the app; many keep it on their servers
|
Depends on the project; self-hosted means it is yours
|
No, it is on the provider's servers
|
Usually on the builder's cloud
|
| How do you pay? |
Buy a version once, or get it free while the creator runs a free promotion. No subscription, no ads
|
One-time purchase, subscription or in-app purchases
|
Mostly free
|
Monthly or yearly subscription
|
Monthly plan, or pay by usage
|
| Still works if the service shuts down? |
Yes, it is installed locally and works offline
|
Depends on the app; ones that need a server stop
|
Yes, you have the code
|
No, it stops working
|
Hosted apps go offline, unless you exported the code
|
- Yes
- Partly, or it depends
- No
This describes how each platform usually works. Each platform's own rules are what count.
If you make software
What matters: where you start, whether you need to code, how you get listed and how you get paid.
| Question | TopArrow | App stores | GitHub | SaaS apps | AI app builders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Where do you start? |
Modify software that already runs, or start from an official template
|
Build it from scratch
|
Build from scratch, or fork someone's project
|
Build from scratch, and set up servers too
|
Have AI generate it from scratch
|
| Can you do it without coding? |
Yes, an AI coding tool makes the changes
|
No, you need to code
|
No, you need to code
|
No, and you need to run servers
|
Yes
|
| How do you get listed? |
Free sign-up, then a review. A brand-new app needs publishing permission first
|
Developer account and review; some stores charge a yearly fee
|
No barrier, and no review
|
Buy your own servers and domain, and launch it yourself
|
Publish to an address the builder gives you, often on a paid plan
|
| Does the platform handle payment? |
Yes. The platform keeps 20%; the rest goes to creators
|
Yes, and takes a commission
|
No, though you can accept sponsorships
|
No, you set up payments yourself
|
No, you set up payments yourself
|
| Can you sell changes to someone else's software? |
Yes, as a derived version; the original author shares in each sale
|
No, you cannot get the code
|
Depends on the license; the original author is not paid
|
No, you cannot get the code
|
Not applicable
|
| Do you earn when others build on your software? |
Yes. When their version sells, you get a share
|
Does not happen; others cannot get the code
|
No. Others can fork it, but you earn nothing
|
Does not happen; others cannot get the code
|
Not applicable
|
| Do you run your own servers? |
No. The software runs on each user's own device
|
Depends; apps with a backend need them
|
No. People deploy it themselves
|
Yes, and keep them running
|
The builder hosts it, for a monthly fee
|
- Yes
- Partly, or it depends
- No
This describes how each platform usually works. Each platform's own rules are what count.
What each one does well
No platform is right for everything. Pick by what you need to do.
App stores
App Store, Google Play, Microsoft Store
- Good at
- The largest selection, and the easiest way to find and install apps on a phone.
- How TopArrow differs
- You get a finished product; if something does not fit, you wait for an update. TopArrow apps work once installed, and you can change them yourself.
GitHub
Open-source projects on GitHub
- Good at
- Where developers share code and build it together, and where most open-source projects live.
- How TopArrow differs
- It is built for people who code, and what you get is mostly source code. TopArrow is for people who use software: install it and use it, and let AI make the changes. A changed version can be sold, and the original author shares in each sale.
SaaS apps
Paid monthly or yearly, used in a browser or an app
- Good at
- Sign in on any device and pick up where you left off. Good when several people work on the same data.
- How TopArrow differs
- Your data lives with the provider and you keep paying; stop paying, or the service closes, and it is gone. With TopArrow the software and data stay on your own device, with no subscription.
AI app builders
Tools like Lovable and Bolt
- Good at
- One sentence gets you a working prototype. Good for trying out an idea quickly.
- How TopArrow differs
- It starts from nothing, and things tend to break as features pile up. TopArrow starts you with software that already runs, so AI only changes the parts you care about.